Allen Edmonds Alternatives| 6 Best Allen Edmonds Alternatives

People often say the first thing one notices when someone is standing in front of them at a party is their outfit. A crucial factor in having the perfect outfit is footwear.

According to the majority of people, the best dress shoe brand is Allen Edmonds. It goes without a doubt, as Allen Edmonds is known for their top quality and comfort. However, the shoes are very expensive, and one may ask, what are some Allen Edmonds alternatives?

Several brands can be good Allen Edmonds alternatives with the textile industry on the rise – such as Allonsi, Cole Haan, Skechers, Stacy Adams, etc. These brands, in fact, are solid rivals of Allen Edmonds when it comes to offering similar quality, comfort, and durability in dress shoes.

If you want to know more about these alternatives and their pros and cons, continue reading the article.

Best Allen Edmonds Alternatives- A Quick Glance Comparison

Best Allen Edmonds Alternatives- A Quick Glance Comparison

Allen Edmonds is an American brand founded in 1922 that specializes in men’s dress shoes. They are well respected for their high-quality shoes. Their shoes are extremely lightweight and flexible. In addition to that, Allen Edmonds is renowned for using very high-quality leather.

However, over the years, the brand has seen some quality drops.

As per one review, the leather was dry and hard, with several defects. At the same time, another customer claimed that the heel broke off after very little use. Not to mention the Allen Edmonds are extremely expensive.

Due to all of this, it’s a great time to look into some Allen Edmonds Alternatives.

NO.Allen Edmonds AlternativesComfortCostDurability Disadvantages
1.Allonsi Genuine Leather Chelsea BootsHighModerateHighPoor quality zipper
2.Cole Haan Men’s Original Grand Shortwing Oxford ShoeModerateExpensive HighProne to damage from water
3.Skechers for Work Men’s Cottonwood Elks Slip Resistant ShoeLowAffordableModerateLow heel quality4.Stacy Adams Men’s Tinsley Wingtip Lace-Up OxfordHighExpensiveHighIt can get damaged if in contact with water
5.Kenneth Cole Men’s Unlisted Half Time OxfordHighAffordableModerateThe shoe deforms over time
6.Deer Stags Men’s Greenpoint.Low.Affordable.Moderate.Low-quality insole.

When discussing alternatives, the first brand that comes to mind is Allonsi Genuine’s leather Chelsea boots. These boots are made of high-quality leather and have a lightweight sole to provide great comfort.

Another great alternative is Cole Haan’s dress shoes. These shoes have excellent soles and are as stylish as you can get.

The third shoe on the list is the Sketchers dress shoe. Yes, sketchers might not be a brand specializing in dress shoes, but theirs haven’t certainly disappointed our experts.

Stacy Adams is another name that comes into mind when considering an Allen Edmonds Alternative. Their dress shoes are known to remain classic looks-wise but with a premium touch that won’t break your bank account.

The fifth alternative you would suggest is Kennet Cole’s men’s dress shoes. These shoes are extremely durable and cheap at the same time.

The last dress shoe on this list is Deer Stag’s dress shoes. These shoes stand out with their laceless design and quality that can compete with Allen Edmonds.

6 Best Allen Edmonds Alternatives

Now that you have an overview of these dress shoes. Let us dive into some detailed information.

1) Allonsi Genuine Leather Chelsea Boots

allen edmonds alternative

If you are looking for dress shoes that are attractive and can be worn on most occasions, Allonsi Genuine Leather Chelsea boots should be your first choice. They get made with pre-quality leather and are known to be extremely rigid and durable.

Even though the shoes are very strong, the leather used is soft and comforting. The materials help prevent excessive sweating and odor creation. So you can stay refreshed and revitalized for longer.

Product Details

  • Package Dimensions: ‎ 13.4 x 9.6 x 4.8 inches; 3.2 pounds.
  • Item model number: ‎ ALM2005.
  • Department: ‎ Men’s.
  • Date First Available: ‎ November 19, 2018.
  • Manufacturer: ‎ Treespoon Private Limited.

Key Features:

The first feature that is a must mention is the thermoplastic elastomers sole. These soles are lightweight and provide comfort similar to athletic shoes. Furthermore, they have great shock absorption.

In addition to that, the shoes are crafted with genuine cow leather. This premium leather gives the shoe a very long lifespan. The leather is soft to touch and has high breathability. Resulting in dry feet at all times.

Moreover, these shoes feature a comfortable elastic side panel which helps keep the shoe firm and in place. They keep the shoe locked to your ankle without any abrasion. It helps prevent sore feet as less pressure is applied.


  • Breathable.
  • Durable.
  • Shock absorbent sole.
  • 100% leather.
  •  Variety of colors to choose from.


  • It can get easily scuffed.
  • Hard to work a zipper.

2) Cole Haan Men’s Original Grand Shortwing Oxford Shoe

Cole Haan Men's Original Grand Shortwing Oxford Shoe

Cole Haan is another alternative that can easily rival Allen Edmons with their grand shortwing oxford shoe. These shoes are known for being extremely stylish and straightforward in style.

The shoes are really well stitched, which makes them a shoe comparatively more durable than Allen Edmonds. However, they cost a little higher; their features are worth the price you pay.

Furthermore, it also claims its grand OS comfort technology provides the ultimate experience compared to other dress shoes on the market.

Product Description

  • Product Dimensions: ‎ 13.5 x 7.6 x 4.8 inches; 12 Ounces.
  • Item model number: ‎ C26470.
  • Department: ‎ Men’s.
  • Date First Available: ‎ June 1, 2017.
  • Manufacturer: ‎ Cole Haan.

Key Features

This Cole Haan shoe comes in classic style, giving off similar vibes to Allen Edmonds. This feature makes the shoe a good alternative.

The shoe features high-quality suede leather that gives extreme comfort. The material is soft to wear and goes not injure your feet. Their comfort technology makes the shoe wearable for an extended period of time without your feet hurting.

It also has a rubber sole that gives your feet good stability and traction on all terrains.

It also features natural storm welt and comes in several colors.


  • Lightweight
  • Various color options
  • Extremely durable.
  • Wing tip


  • Hardly withstand water or any other wetness.
  • Some claimed the leather got crinkled after a few wears.

3) Skechers for Work Men’s Cottonwood Elks Slip Resistant Shoe

Skechers for Work Men's Cottonwood Elks Slip Resistant Shoe

Sketchers is certainly not a brand that comes to mind when considering Allen Edmon’s alternatives. However, over the year, Sketchers have launched a series of dress shoes, such as the Cottonwood Elk, which are worth checking out.

This shoe has a classic black design making it suitable for the most formal occasion while providing high comfort. They also have high slip resistance and can withstand water and other substances.

Product Details

  • Product Dimensions: ‎ 10 x 15 x 6 inches; 1.2 pounds.
  • Item model number: ‎ 77041.
  • Department: ‎ Men’s.
  • Date First Available: ‎ October 31, 2014.
  • Manufacturer: ‎ Skechers for Work.

Key Features

The most crucial feature to mention about these shoes is that the soles are completely man-made. The soles are made with 100% precision and authenticity while keeping quality in mind.

Furthermore, the shoes have a unique relaxed fit technology that helps them mold to the shape of your feet. Providing great comfort. In addition, the memory foam makes sure your feet have constant support when walking.

Lastly, the shaft that measures exactly 3 inches from the arch provides good arch support. Therefore, you can go longer wearing the shoes.


  • Slip-resistant.
  • Affordable.
  • Can withstand water.
  • Provides good support.


  • The heel does not last long.

4)Stacy Adams Men’s Tinsley Wingtip Lace-Up Oxford

Stacy Adams Men's Tinsley Wingtip Lace-Up Oxford

These Stacy Adams shoes are absolutely classic and a great alternative to Allen Edmonds with their classic wing tip lace-up oxford design with features brogue perforated trims and blind eye lacing.

They provide 5 different colors to choose from and have high-quality soles.

The lightweight construction of the shoe makes it really durable. Alongside durability, it also has a breathable lining to keep your feet healthy – which means no odor, no sweat.

Product Detail

  • Product Dimensions: ‎ 13.9 x 7.4 x 4.5 inches; 12 Ounces.
  • Item model number: ‎ 25092-001.
  • Department: ‎ Men’s.
  • Date First Available: ‎ November 17, 2016.
  • Manufacturer: ‎ Stacy Adams.

Key Features

This shoe’s key feature is the leather sole alongside the body being made with 100% leather. While most soles are made of rubber or other synthetic material, this leather sole provides great flexibility.

Furthermore, it has a specialized criss-cross etching, with is brilliant for maximum traction. It ensures that you don’t slip on those slippery floors.

Moreover, the OS comfort Technology makes a fully cushioned memory foam insole that keeps the shoe comfortable even when worn for long hours. Alongside that, the shoe also has a breathable lining.

Lastly, the shoe also features a good amount of shock absorption.


  • Durable.
  • Breathable.
  • Good grip.
  • High-quality leather.
  • Padded cushions.


  • Prone to damage if in contact with water.
  • Not always accurate with color.

5) Kenneth Cole Men’s Unlisted Half Time Oxford

Kenneth Cole Men's Unlisted Half Time Oxford

The 5th alternative to Allen Edmonds is the Kenneth cole men’s shoe. The shoes are available in 3 colors that match your style perfectly.

Being more affordable makes it a good choice if you don’t want to break your wallet purchasing Allen Edmonds. Just because they are cheaper in price does not mean the brand sacrifices in quality. Trust me; the comfort and quality are top-notch.

Kennet Cole is known for their good quality shoe, and this one does not disappoint. Its padded insole provides great comfort and is extremely subtle on your feet.

Product Detail

  • Product Dimensions: ‎ 13 x 8 x 5 inches; 14.2 Ounces.
  • Item model number: ‎ UM31072SY.
  • Department: ‎ Men’s.
  • Date First Available: ‎ October 1, 2015.
  • Manufacturer: ‎ Kenneth Cole.

Key Feature

This shoe’s notable feature is its durable faux leather upper. It gives the shoe a very polished look while maintaining the classic cap-toe oxford dress shoe look.

The padded insole gives the shoe day-long wearability. It is also 100% synthetic which includes a synthetic sole.

The sole molds according to the shape of your feet, giving a perfect fit.

The rubber outsole is also durable and provides good balance and grip when walking.


  • Affordable.
  • Durable.
  • Waxed laces.
  • Lace-up design.


  • Some customers found the shoe deforming about a few wears.

6) Deer Stags Men’s Greenpoint

Deer Stags Men's Greenpoint

The last shoe on this list is Deer Stags Greenpoint. This shoe is also affordable, making them a suitable budget-friendly alternative to Allen Edmunds.

Despite being a budget dress shoe, it has a remarkably clean and class design like Allen Edmonds and features extremely fashionable stitching details.

Product Details

  • Product Dimensions: ‎ 5 x 5 x 0.7 inches; 12 Ounces.
  • Item model number: ‎ Greenpoint.
  • Department: ‎ Men’s.
  • Date First Available: ‎ October 4, 2005.
  • Manufacturer: ‎ Deer Stags.

Key Feature

The most notable feature this shoe has is its durable man-made outsole. The outsoles are of high quality and are extremely sturdy.

In addition, it has a padded sock and collar to provide as much comfort as possible without causing any issues to your feet.

It also has slip-on technology with dual-sided elastic goring, making the shoe very easy to wear.

The shoe comprises 100% simulated leather and features a stacked heel.


  • Affordable.
  • Laceless.
  • 1.5-inch heel.
  • Easy to wear.


  • The insoles start coming out after a few uses.

What To Consider When Choosing A Dress Shoe

What To Consider When Choosing A Dress Shoe

Dress shoes can be a very expensive investment. So, knowing how to choose the perfect dress shoe is important. There are certain things that you have to know before purchasing any dress shoe.

Here are some things you should consider before choosing a dress shoe.

  • Material

We suggest always going for shoes that use natural material rather than synthetic. Because there are several benefits of choosing natural materials, such as they last longer, look better, and are more breathable.

  • Perfect Fit

Dress shoes are in no way comfortable if they are a size smaller or bigger than your actual size. It is very crucial to buy the right sized shoe. Wearing loose shoes will cause several feet injury, and wearing smaller shoes can be extremely uncomfortable.

We suggest always trying the shoe out before purchasing.   A perfectly fit shoe will not be snuggly and will have enough space at the front for your toes to move.

Choose Shoe According To Your Feet Shape

This is another important thing to remember. As different styles fit different feet types. Not all shoes are wearable for people with wide feet. Buying a shoe that does not fit your feet shape will result in feeling restrained and constant pain.


  • Who competes with Allen Edmons?

Allen Edmonds might have been the sharks of the footwear industry during some point in their existence, but now they certainly aren’t.

Several brands can go head-on and compete with Allen Edmonds, such as Cole Haan, Sketchers, Johnston and Murphy, etc.

  • Are Allen Edmonds high quality?

Yes, they are; in fact, Allen Edmonds is one of the highest quality dress shoes available in the market.

  • Who is Allen Edmonds owned by?

On December 14, 2021, Caleres, the parent company of famous footwear, acquired Allen Edmonds for $255 million.

Bottom Line

We know it’s hard to resist purchasing high-quality shoes such as Allen Edmonds, but if you are on a budget and are looking for Allen Edmonds alternatives, then the above six mentioned shoes are worth checking out.

All those shoes are comparatively more affordable, and each has better features than Allen Edmonds. The 6 alternatives are indeed highly comfortable and worth the buck.

Leave a Comment